A new stimulus proposal backed by Elon Musk and supported by former President Donald Trump is making waves. Dubbed the “DOGE Dividend,” the plan would distribute a portion of government savings directly to taxpayers, with some reports suggesting households could receive up to $5,000 each.
The proposal comes from investor James Fishback, who suggested using savings from the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) to reward taxpayers. Trump recently endorsed the idea, and Musk, known for his interest in cutting wasteful spending, has voiced support.
But how does this plan compare to past stimulus checks, and is it even realistic? Let’s break it down.
How It Compares to Past Stimulus Checks
Historically, stimulus checks have been used during economic crises to boost spending and prevent recessions. Here’s a quick look at past direct payments from the U.S. government:
- March 2020: $1,200 per adult + $500 per child (CARES Act)
- December 2020: $600 per adult + $600 per child (Consolidated Appropriations Act)
- March 2021: $1,400 per adult + $1,400 per dependent (American Rescue Plan)
In total, over $800 billion was distributed through these COVID-era payments to help struggling Americans.
Now, the DOGE Dividend promises $5,000 per household, which is significantly higher than any previous single stimulus payment. However, there are key differences in how this plan would work.
Key Differences Between the DOGE Dividend and Past Stimulus Checks
-
Where the Money Comes From
Past stimulus checks were funded through government borrowing, adding to the national debt. The DOGE Dividend, however, aims to use savings from reducing wasteful government spending instead of borrowing money. -
Who Would Get the Money
Unlike past payments, which were based on income levels, the DOGE Dividend would likely go only to households that pay federal income taxes. That means millions of lower-income Americans who don’t owe federal taxes might not qualify. -
Why the Payments Are Being Considered
Previous stimulus checks were emergency relief during financial crises, such as the Great Recession or the COVID-19 pandemic. The DOGE Dividend, on the other hand, is more of a “thank you” payout for taxpayers, rather than a measure to boost the economy.
Challenges and Potential Roadblocks
While the idea of a $5,000 check sounds exciting, there are serious hurdles in making it a reality.
-
Where Are the Savings?
The DOGE Department has reported only $55 billion in government savings so far. The proposed payments would require $400 billion, so there’s a massive shortfall in funding. -
Congress Needs to Approve It
Even if Trump and Musk support it, Congress would have to pass legislation for these checks to go out. Lawmakers might prefer to use the savings for national debt reduction or infrastructure projects instead. -
Could It Cause Inflation?
Economists warn that dropping billions of dollars into the economy could increase inflation, just like the COVID-era stimulus checks did.
Final Thoughts: Will It Happen?
The DOGE Dividend is an ambitious and unique proposal, but there are many uncertainties surrounding it. While Musk and Trump’s support has made headlines, funding, congressional approval, and inflation concerns could prevent it from becoming reality.
For now, it’s a wait-and-see situation. If the savings materialize and lawmakers back it, this could be one of the largest taxpayer payments in U.S. history. Until then, Americans should stay informed and cautious about expecting a check in the mail anytime soon.
